A neighborhood of Islands of Jupiter · Jupiter, Florida
Compass Island, Islands of Jupiter
Twenty-two custom homes on SE Compass Island Way, built mostly 1997 to 2000, on the North Fork of the Loxahatchee River in the gated Islands of Jupiter.
Homes, years and sizes: Martin County property records (2025 tax roll).
Overview
About Compass Island
Compass Island is twenty-two single-family homes on SE Compass Island Way, built mostly from 1997 to 2000, typically about 3,000 square feet on lots of about a third of an acre, the smallest homes in the Islands.
More on Islands of Jupiter, from its history to what is nearby, is in our Islands of Jupiter neighborhood guide.
It is platted separately, as the Second Addition of Jupiter River Estates, and shares the Islands association. Listings describe gated entrances; we confirm how the gates are staffed.
At a glance
- Streets
- SE Compass Island Way
- Home type
- Single-family waterfront homes
- Built
- 1997 to 2000
- Living area
- About 2,670 to 4,430 sq ft
- Typical lot
- About 0.36 acres
- Association
- The Islands of Jupiter Property Owners Association, Inc.
- Manager
- Coastal Property Management
- Zip code
- 33458
- Jurisdiction
- Unincorporated Martin County
On the market now
Homes for Sale in Compass Island
Listings inside the recorded boundary of Compass Island, newest first, updated through the day from BeachesMLS. No homes are listed for sale here right now. New listings come up through the year; ask me to watch for one.
No properties found
All listings featuring the BMLS logo are provided by BeachesMLS, Inc. This information is not verified for authenticity or accuracy and is not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 BeachesMLS, Inc. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by BeachesMLS. Listings held by brokerage firms other than Douglas Elliman Real Estate are identified with the listing firm’s name on each listing’s detail page. Listing data is refreshed at least every 12 hours.
Closed sales
The Compass Island Market
Closed sales inside the boundary of Compass Island. With 22 homes, a year can bring only a handful of sales, so we read each one with you rather than lean on an average.
Three closed sales in twelve months is a thin sample, so read the median as a marker, not a price for any one home. We pull every closing here for any home you are considering.
| Measure | Last 12 months |
|---|---|
| Homes sold | 3 |
| Median sale price | $3,050,000 |
| Median price per sq ft | $941 |
| Active listings now | 0 |
BeachesMLS closed sales inside the boundary of Compass Island, twelve months through October 2026, via IDX Broker. Active listings now is live from the MLS feed; the median asking price updates monthly. Listing information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Association and costs
The Compass Island Association and What It Costs
| Neighborhood association | The Islands of Jupiter Property Owners Association, Inc. |
|---|---|
| Florida corporate record | Sunbiz document N35781, filed December 22, 1989 (opens in a new tab) |
| Management company | Coastal Property Management |
| Governed by | Chapter 720, Florida Statutes (homeowners’ associations) |
| One association for the Islands | All six Islands streets share The Islands of Jupiter Property Owners Association; no separate island association is on record with the State. |
Association Fees From Current Listings
| Association fee, median | $271 a month |
|---|---|
| Typical range | $269 to $300 a month |
| Usually covers | Common Areas, Security, Cable TV |
| Club membership | Not required |
From 3 current and recent BeachesMLS listings in Compass Island, via IDX Broker, refreshed weekly. Fees are monthly equivalents of the association fees in each listing; condo, master and sub-association fees can stack. The recorded documents, the current budget and the estoppel govern.
The boundary
Compass Island on the Map
Questions
Questions Buyers Ask About Compass Island
Is Compass Island part of the Islands of Jupiter?
Yes. Listings treat it as one of the Islands enclaves and it shares The Islands of Jupiter Property Owners Association. It is recorded as the Second Addition of Jupiter River Estates.
How many homes are in Compass Island, and when were they built?
Martin County property records list 22 homes in Compass Island, with most built 1997 to 2000. The typical living area is about 3,020 square feet on about 0.36 acres.
More of Islands of Jupiter
The Other Neighborhoods of Islands of Jupiter
Compass Island · Islands of Jupiter · Jupiter
Own in Compass Island?
Tell us the street and we send back what homes in Compass Island have sold for, what is listed now, and what we would expect yours to bring. Buying here instead? We gather the listings, the association’s fees and rules, and arrange the visits.
Monika Phillips, Sales Associate, Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Home counts, years built and sizes come from Martin County property records (2025 tax roll) and recorded plats; association records from the Florida Division of Corporations; school zones from the Martin County School District. Listing and sales data from BeachesMLS via IDX is deemed reliable but not guaranteed; listings may be held by brokerages other than Douglas Elliman. Association fees shown come from current and recent listings and can differ from the association’s budget; recorded documents and the associations’ own figures control. Verify anything that matters to your decision with the source. Monika Phillips, Sales Associate, Douglas Elliman Real Estate. Equal Housing Opportunity.
